love and logic

her: if i ate a poison apple, i'd be sick
me: yeees, that's probably true  

her: like gisele was sick 

me: well, you don't have to worry about that
her: gisele was sick when she ate the poison apple that the witch gave her
me: yes ... 
[pause, thinking this one through]
me: okay, but where was gisele from? and the witch and the poison apples? andalasia, right?
her: yes
me: and do we live in andalasia?
her: no
me: see? nothing to worry about